DEBATE BEWEEN SCIENCE & RELIGION.
Term Paper ID:28988
|
|
|
Essay Subject:
Discusses Darwin's theory of cause & change (Origin of Species). & religious viewpoint.... More...
|
13 Pages / 2925 Words
4 sources, 18 Citations,
APA Format
$52.00
Return to List of Papers
|
Paper Abstract:
Discusses Darwin's theory of cause & change (Origin of Species) & religioius viewpoint. Philosophjy of natural theology & God. Theories of creation, theory of Evolution. Darwin's evidence & observations & theory of common descent. Religious & secular beliefs of Darwin's time.
Paper Introduction:
When Darwin published his book, Origin of Species, he sparked off a huge debate between the authority of science and that of religion. The debate continues even today. This paper will look at Darwin=s theory of cause and change, and the corresponding religious viewpoint.
According to the philosophy of natural theology widely accepted in England in Darwin=s time, God had designed, and looked after, every species and its numerous adaptations (Mayr, 1991, p. 14). Darwin could not accept this explanation of the enormous diversity and adaption he observed. His own observations were also in conflict with the belief of the theologians in a perfect world. He questioned why all the species from former periods were extinct if they were perfect. To Darwin, creation as described in the bible was contradicted by al
Text of the Paper:
The entire text of the paper is shown below. However, the text is somewhat scrambled. We want to give you as much information as we possibly can about our papers and essays, but we cannot give them away for free. In the text below you will find that while disordered, many of the phrases are essentially intact. From this text you will be able to get a solid sense of the writing style, the concepts addressed, and the sources used in the research paper.
will look at Darwin s theory ofcause numerous adaptations Mayr p Darwin could not all the species from former hierarchy of types oforganisms that had been proposed by Linnaeus explain the emergence and gradual perfection for existence existswhich leads to the classification ofspecies Aonly strongly marked and permanent varieties there were usually many varieties of featured in most taxonomic schemes Darwin also claimedthe theory of ofsurviving at variance with what would be assumed if dived to feed onsubaquatic prey every availableniche and thus creatures which could adapt to defense system for the bee The youngichneumonidae did the occasional appearance of stripes on theshoulders and legs later related forms Brooks p Geographical distribution of separation from the mainland Darwin that in an environment characterized in domesticated plants and animals After readingThomas Malthus of plants and animals Although would survive to have the greatest number of a new species Darwin s theory oftransmutation provided individuals for whom the organs has to migration and divergent variation from the center oforigin Although theliving world that was missing be traced back to a common origin Everything had seemed higher taxon consisted of descendants or the gill arches in fishesand some form into which living powershad been Abreathed into Brooke it was impossible to provide transmutation didnot help his cause To explain this at the same time rejecting the doctrine of specialcreation He world and its Creator Darwin concluded his book Origin a wide range of organisms Brooke p para line recanted the useof the word Creator saying that he meant Darwin s theory did not touch onthe central in a constant world In itwas still largely accepted that and the existing diversity due to world and adaption of organisms to their physical creation because he possessed a soul animals didnot This left s theory a belief in processes of nature as they and that even though changingconditions could a design andpurpose and a mutual adaptation of parts due to a power above those established are found which he believes were Owen alsodisputed Darwin s theory Hovenkamp in favor of creationism He believed nature adopted for peopling the light on the questionof God s transcendence over and immanence in His creation forms pointed to thecontinuous involvement of that being of His immanence Evolutionary perspectives allowed a as a continued participant in the evolutionary process that such evolution had takenplace increase insurvival fitness the earlier forms would have then proposed that change was brought about bynatural selection those change accordingto Darwin s theories His evidence came time his evidence therefore coming more direct evidence which canbe climatic changes changes in available foodstuffs etc However it in fossil records Fossil records are used bytheologists as concept of a supreme being God and hiscontinued can besubjected to scientific proof though this proof is sometimes causes ascribed to species changes Darwin s theory for example and the presence of vestigial then what would be the reason anything less than perfect Theologistssay terms of reason and proof References J H Darwinism and the divine in authority of science and that of theology widely accepted inEngland in Darwin s time in conflict with the belief of the theologiansin the natural world and itcould not explain but simply underwent such drastic transformation that formerly existingtypes could occur second that variations could occur inthese his theory indicatedthat there could be species fell into a pattern in a region where many convergence from common ancestors could give a historicalexplanation for a few greatclasses Brooke p To explain his theory did not swim birds resembling woodpeckers which survived bypicking theory that as each species was striving to the sting of a bee consistent with a beneficentGod The presence of vestigial or rudimentary evolutionary divergence meshedwith fossil records the more species with the inhabitants of the nearest in a species that might explainhow adaption took Darwin found evidence of this in the organisms generated a competitive struggleamong individuals within a species This species and reasoned that in a struggle forlimited After many generations the remaining population ofindividuals would example rudimentary organs whichserved no purpose could organisms could beattributed to common ancestry and the geographical Its importancelay in its explanatory powers and the fact an entirely different perspective when of common descent and now it all mademore sense The explained in dispersal of ancestors Similarities suchas the of a common ancestor Darwin even anticipated genetic code as plants and animals Darwin conceded that fordescent by modification was the fact of artificial selection reviewers so heexplicitly credited God fundamental to the way most religious thinkers conceived living powers Abreathedinto a few thus admitting a role forreligion that a Christiandoctrine of creation need not entail the p In Darwin s time there were four common religious had not changed materially sinceit was created Secondly Although imperfections were acknowledged it was Creator Lastly the world was anthropocentric beliefs there were three secularbeliefs which reflection of alimited number of constant and cause of everything Mayr pps Adam Sedgwick Hovenkamp and flourish but the causation of these new thatthe introduction of a new phenomenon unaccounted that by looking at different no evidence of intermediate forms contraryto what Darwin found classification is the task of science and nature Likewise Sir Joseph Dalton Hooker held to the hypothesis unchangedthrough many generations were called species Hovenkamp concept of design some Christianwriters now proclaimed that Darwinism to be the work ofa transcendent being Godoccasionally intruded with miraculous acts of creation had the s continual involvement withthe world he created British physiologist showed how the simplest spiralshell had gradually developed into theory of natural selectioncould not apply here biologists of Darwin s time thusperpetuating their particular adaptions to a beneficial qualities as their subjects He also used fossil couldbe construed as being circumstantial and changes andthat He does this the only cause for theappearance of new species as the Creator and his as the Creator of all proof of His existence is present only inthe distribution of species species behaving in If God is thought to be best possible world But how could this be true first place this would not benecessary This in America Universityof Pennsylvania Press When Darwin published his book Origin of Species he sparked and change and the corresponding religious viewpoint acceptthis explanation of the enormous diversity periodswere extinct if they were perfect To Darwin creation as or many of the other findingsof ofvarious species by three propositions the preservation of profitable deviations of a structure orinstinct Brooke p para lines Darwin s theory could that speciesproduced This followed if all creation could not explain why all forms of life could they had been speciallycreated he used examples such Preadaption to preexisting conditions could not explainthese phenomena Brooke p new environments wouldsurvive Darwin s theory of evolution could feeding on the living bodies of caterpillars was a of horses explicable if they species could be explained byspecies in s own observations showed him that by constant change some variants would be better Essay on the Principle of Population his predecessors had looked mainly at the progeny Inturn the best adapted of these a scientific explanation for phenomena that played adaptive roles Roberts p Similarly if the theory of common descent was not invented by Darwin until that time The diversity of to be arbitrary or chaotic of a still moreremote ancestor Patterns of distribution terrestrial tetrapods had been totally p para line To thisend modern-day developments such because the process worked soslowly The closest one he stressed the fragmentary nature ofthe geological record Darwin was thus challenging a vision of species with the proclamation thatthere was a He also referred to laws ofnature to refer to a wholly doctrine that everything ultimately owed its existence andpreservation to the world was a relatively new creation creation Thirdly it wasbelieved that the world and livingenvironments was believed to no possible transition from animal the philosophyof essentialism all the had beenelaborated by physicists and cause a species to die out new that above and exterior to thephenomena of nature was laws though it was acting in conformity with them Sedgwick createdbecause of the different conditions existing at different times during p He insisted thatevidence of form structure and procreative phenomena that species likeevery other group was a globe with diverse existingforms which continued involvement with the world The laws of naturethat allowed in the creative process Apologistsof the time observed that more balanced view An evolvinguniverse by comparingancient and modern forms of Foramenifera a group of along a definite course with each stage being one of been exterminated over time This form of reasoning leading organisms most suitable for survival under operantconditions would from direct observation of thedistribution of various species and the both from historical evidence and readily observed and substantiated and is not open to gives no explanation ofwhy such historical evidence but the theory comes involvement the world and its evolution The importance of the slow incoming whereas the latter is not as presents reasons for adaptive changes and explains manyfacts organs In thecase of natural theology for documented changes If thereis need for change then the that changes prove His continued involvement with Brooke J H Science and religion Cambridge UK Cambridge University America Madison WI University of religion Thedebate continues even today This paper God had designed and looked after every speciesand its a perfect world He questioned why the fossil record nor the were changed beyond recognition Darwin felt he could organs and instincts and third a struggle no clear lines drawn between species of a genushad been produced the pyramidal hierarchical arrangement of groups withingroups that was of creatures which had developed ways insects from the ground and thrushes which increase itsnumbers natural selection favored the exploitation of the bee dies once it has stungsomeone hardly a perfect organs also favored Darwin stheory of evolution as ancient the fossil the more often itdisplayed characteristics intermediate between mainland wascomprehensible if migration preceded place by means of secondary agencies Roberts pp He reasoned work of breeders who selecteddesired characteristics was responsible for maintainingrelatively stable populations resources individuals better adapted to the prevailingcircumstances have diverged from the ancestral population sufficientlyto merit designation as be explained as the result of inheritance fromearlier distribution of speciescould be ascribed that it provided a unity for itwas realized that it could all Linnean hierarchy became logical because it becameapparent that each chorda in tunicates and vertebrates thatall plant and animal life descended from evidence for transmutation was lacking butargued that Unfortunately the lack of paleontological evidence for with having impressed on matter the laws governingthe universe while of therelationship between the organic simple forms which later evolved into in his theory of evolution though in private he view that every species had beenindependently created They claimed that beliefs Mayr pp The first was a belief species and other taxa were believed to beunchanging believed to be the bestpossible man having aunique position in the were at odds with Darwin sharply delimited essences a belief in aninterpretation of the causal p believed that species hadbeen constant for thousands of years species musthave been creation He insisted that although there was for by the operation ofany known law of nature was layers ofthe earth different species when examining fossil records Sir Richard species the work ofnature all argued that variation was themeans which p A theology informed by Darwinism could shed some gave them a new understanding ofGod s but the emergence of new defects ofemphasizing His transcendence at the expense William Carpenter claimed to have found evidenceof God a complex cyclical form through anapparently regular progression He concluded because if each stage represented an remained popular amongreligious apologists Darwin s theories particular set ofcircumstances Survival was thus the driving force behind records to show adaptive changes in species over open to interpretation ongoingevidence such as the breeding programs is according to the needs of time such as It cites as evidence the paucity ofintermediate forms omnipotence This latterrequires total acceptance of the things is that the former mind of believers In terms of the ways for which they were not uniquely designed theupland goose omnipotent and his world the best possiblecreation if God is indeedomnipotent Why would he create makes Darwin s theory more plausible in Mayr E One long argument Cambridge Mass HarvardUniversity Press Roberts off ahuge debate between the According to the philosophy of natural and adaption he observed Hisown observations were also described in thebible was contradicted by almost every aspect of science Linnaeus had proposed that no organism ever became extinct first that gradations in perfectionin organs and species Using these propositions Darwin showed how also explain how the geographical distributionof a species first existed as varieties Healso showed that beplaced in groups subordinate to other groups all within as upland goose which although it hadwebbed feet These example however could beexplained by the also explain examples of imperfectadaption such as similarexample and neither of these seemed to be had descended from aprior species Further evidence came from repeated a particular location sharing the same ancestors The affinityof island there were numerous slight hereditable differences among individuals adapted to survival than the originalspecies i e transmutation occurred Darwin saw thatpopulation pressure among competition betweenspecies Darwin looked within progeny would themselves leave a greaternumber of descendants specialcreationists had regarded as facts For Darwin s hypothesis were correct embryologicaland morphological similarities among different hewas the first to adopt it consistently Mayr p plant andanimal life in the world took on in natural historyuntil Darwin came up with the theory that had previously seemedcapricious could be mystifying until they wereinterpreted as vestiges as DNA sequencing have demonstrated thateven bacteria have the same could come to providing empirical evidence did not want to generate anger from his pious of natural history that hadbecome grandeur to his view of life which saw being imparted to matter by the Creator unknownprocess Open-minded religious commentators often emphasized a power transcending the natural order Brooke andthat except for minor perturbations it was designed by a wise and benign Creator be perfect because it had been designed by anomnipotent to man Along with these four religious variable phenomena of nature are a a belief in teleology final causes Godbeing the final species might have hadroom to occur a prescient and designing cause He proposed went on to point out thelifetime of the earth He saw and the truth ofthe fact that creation of the brain not of when they tended to transmit their characters Brooke pp Although it challenged the traditional the evolutionary process to occur were said a mechanistic universe into which provided tangible evidence of a God simple marineorganisms Brooke pp He progress and ofpreparation for the next He argued that the to a theological conclusion althoughincreasingly rare among be those who produced the most offspring fact that breeders selectedanimals and plants with particular fromsources outside history ongoing sources While historical evidence differentinterpretations Natural theology proposes that only God can bring about changes took place It proposes creation as mainly from thesupreme belief in God differences between a belief in Darwinism and abelief in God easy to substantiate Since theconcept of God is intangible the known in his time such as the geographical the causes for change are not as clearly defined world as it was originally created was notthe His creation but ifHe created the perfect world in the Press Hovenkamp H Science and religion Wisconsin Press will look at Darwin s theory ofcause numerous adaptations Mayr p Darwin could not all the species from former hierarchy of types oforganisms that had been proposed by Linnaeus explain the emergence and gradual perfection for existence existswhich leads to the classification ofspecies Aonly strongly marked and permanent varieties there were usually many varieties of featured in most taxonomic schemes Darwin also claimedthe theory of ofsurviving at variance with what would be assumed if dived to feed onsubaquatic prey every availableniche and thus creatures which could adapt to defense system for the bee The youngichneumonidae did the occasional appearance of stripes on theshoulders and legs later related forms Brooks p Geographical distribution of separation from the mainland Darwin that in an environment characterized in domesticated plants and animals After readingThomas Malthus of plants and animals Although would survive to have the greatest number of a new species Darwin s theory oftransmutation provided individuals for whom the organs has to migration and divergent variation from the center oforigin Although theliving world that was missing be traced back to a common origin Everything had seemed higher taxon consisted of descendants or the gill arches in fishesand some form into which living powershad been Abreathed into Brooke it was impossible to provide transmutation didnot help his cause To explain this at the same time rejecting the doctrine of specialcreation He world and its Creator Darwin concluded his book Origin a wide range of organisms Brooke p para line recanted the useof the word Creator saying that he meant Darwin s theory did not touch onthe central in a constant world In itwas still largely accepted that and the existing diversity due to world and adaption of organisms to their physical creation because he possessed a soul animals didnot This left s theory a belief in processes of nature as they and that even though changingconditions could a design andpurpose and a mutual adaptation of parts due to a power above those established are found which he believes were Owen alsodisputed Darwin s theory Hovenkamp in favor of creationism He believed nature adopted for peopling the light on the questionof God s transcendence over and immanence in His creation forms pointed to thecontinuous involvement of that being of His immanence Evolutionary perspectives allowed a as a continued participant in the evolutionary process that such evolution had takenplace increase insurvival fitness the earlier forms would have then proposed that change was brought about bynatural selection those change accordingto Darwin s theories His evidence came time his evidence therefore coming more direct evidence which canbe climatic changes changes in available foodstuffs etc However it in fossil records Fossil records are used bytheologists as concept of a supreme being God and hiscontinued can besubjected to scientific proof though this proof is sometimes causes ascribed to species changes Darwin s theory for example and the presence of vestigial then what would be the reason anything less than perfect Theologistssay terms of reason and proof References J H Darwinism and the divine in authority of science and that of theology widely accepted inEngland in Darwin s time in conflict with the belief of the theologiansin the natural world and itcould not explain but simply underwent such drastic transformation that formerly existingtypes could occur second that variations could occur inthese his theory indicatedthat there could be species fell into a pattern in a region where many convergence from common ancestors could give a historicalexplanation for a few greatclasses Brooke p To explain his theory did not swim birds resembling woodpeckers which survived bypicking theory that as each species was striving to the sting of a bee consistent with a beneficentGod The presence of vestigial or rudimentary evolutionary divergence meshedwith fossil records the more species with the inhabitants of the nearest in a species that might explainhow adaption took Darwin found evidence of this in the organisms generated a competitive struggleamong individuals within a species This species and reasoned that in a struggle forlimited After many generations the remaining population ofindividuals would example rudimentary organs whichserved no purpose could organisms could beattributed to common ancestry and the geographical Its importancelay in its explanatory powers and the fact an entirely different perspective when of common descent and now it all mademore sense The explained in dispersal of ancestors Similarities suchas the of a common ancestor Darwin even anticipated genetic code as plants and animals Darwin conceded that fordescent by modification was the fact of artificial selection reviewers so heexplicitly credited God fundamental to the way most religious thinkers conceived living powers Abreathedinto a few thus admitting a role forreligion that a Christiandoctrine of creation need not entail the p In Darwin s time there were four common religious had not changed materially sinceit was created Secondly Although imperfections were acknowledged it was Creator Lastly the world was anthropocentric beliefs there were three secularbeliefs which reflection of alimited number of constant and cause of everything Mayr pps Adam Sedgwick Hovenkamp and flourish but the causation of these new thatthe introduction of a new phenomenon unaccounted that by looking at different no evidence of intermediate forms contraryto what Darwin found classification is the task of science and nature Likewise Sir Joseph Dalton Hooker held to the hypothesis unchangedthrough many generations were called species Hovenkamp concept of design some Christianwriters now proclaimed that Darwinism to be the work ofa transcendent being Godoccasionally intruded with miraculous acts of creation had the s continual involvement withthe world he created British physiologist showed how the simplest spiralshell had gradually developed into theory of natural selectioncould not apply here biologists of Darwin s time thusperpetuating their particular adaptions to a beneficial qualities as their subjects He also used fossil couldbe construed as being circumstantial and changes andthat He does this the only cause for theappearance of new species as the Creator and his as the Creator of all proof of His existence is present only inthe distribution of species species behaving in If God is thought to be best possible world But how could this be true first place this would not benecessary This in America Universityof Pennsylvania Press
If this paper is not what you are looking for, you can search again:
or
Click here to request an essay written just for you.
|
|
|
