COUNSELING MODEL VS. THERAPY MODEL.
Term Paper ID:28853
|
|
|
Essay Subject:
Discusses which model is most effective in dealing with children in the public school system who have emotional, behavioral and/or mental health problems.... More...
|
15 Pages / 3375 Words
13 sources, 20 Citations,
APA Format
$120.00
Return to List of Papers
|
Paper Abstract:
Discusses which model is most effective in dealing with children in the public school system who have emotional, behavioral and/or mental health problems.
Paper Introduction:
The Counseling Model vs. the Therapy Model in a Public School Setting
Text of the Paper:
The entire text of the paper is shown below. However, the text is somewhat scrambled. We want to give you as much information as we possibly can about our papers and essays, but we cannot give them away for free. In the text below you will find that while disordered, many of the phrases are essentially intact. From this text you will be able to get a solid sense of the writing style, the concepts addressed, and the sources used in the research paper.
inspecial education rather than removing them from the schools This or other physical issues althoughsome of these students Washington State recently released a report on the emotional and to in children fromage and in to have either behavioral or emotional have problems significant enough to be labeled create problems inthe classroom The focus in this study situation is a school district in which students are therapy model The counseling model is more adolescents but on helping them change problems of theadolescents with treatment addressing that Review of the the model in use is some combination of the schools have sought to address theneeds of these limiting counseling services and providing includes provision of the fullrange and school wideinterventions Weist Weist et al programs and difficulties in evaluation In general schools preferthe more may include approaches that are therapeutic but moresolution-focused and of the problem by using community preventive services and curative or healingresponses to children groupinterviewed administrators from different levels of schools anddifferent geographic schools and were categorized as urban suburban or rural There toprovide open-ended comments on the needs of youth and that an emerging issue is that many the children and theresources already available to them also inadequatedocumentation that services are meeting the the most significant problem inexpanding the scope of ESMH constituencies that ESMHprograms are the the models that use counselingapproaches seen in terms of their deficits that there was reciprocity between theindividual and the individual's environment and theindividual taking personal responsibility for his or aim to identify thosebehaviors which work for inwhich the problem does not see himself or herself in other terms It supportsan image the child tosucceed more and more often This reinforces the clearlythings that do not work approach which acknowledges that systems tend to getstuck If In other words the same old models will elicit would tend tochange the whole system leading change This is a very different been placed on medications They have been put in possible to createa system within the classroom itself that it the aspect of unconditional care Thisbuilds on the Rogerian approach rejectionthat most children have already experienced by the of staff teachers and counselors so that they are this solution-focused systemic approach isindividualization The intent is to create the question of what the child needs so that the school that determines what behaviors needs to be empowering Whetherit is acceptable to individual the counselor and the school This may and personal responsibility thedifference is that the Harmonium Project He indicated that one of thecore even if the school environment does not they are able tosucceed Instead to introduce these concepts tothem and model them for healing and growth Laveman ashome friends and school They then help the child to wascooperativeness With support from teachers and parents he was of the systems This is onlylikely to occur to Weil people need to know they are as ineffective in many instances in termsof generalizability and transferability Evans et al believe that the social skills trainingparadigm can students with learning disabilities having rejected by peers andexcluded from ordinary social interactions because have different skills andweaknesses a general program is likely programming What Evans et al recommend for improvingsocial skills to generalize these skills to different settings within theschool adaptable to a counselingapproach within common-sense basis of theapproach Conclusion There program aremore cost effective and that they schools with a largepercentage of their population dealing with which are widespread such as social are confused in their intentions andcontradictory in goals that I am presented with support amore long-term beserved and how they are to be served The counseling tracked into specialeducation classes They have may be better served by focusingefforts on explored above provide a means for changed behaviors affecting the system in disturbed children and adolescents Burlington VT Universityof States History current models andneeds Community Mental Madden M Report reveals mental health of state's kids The system of care for children and adolescents T H Ollendick and R J Prinz Eds McNeil D W Expandedschool mental health has increasingly dealt with children withemotional The issues with thesestudents are different than issues for students problem in the schoolsystem it might be helpful to and emotional problems that are serious enough towarrant some DSM categories Boys children from single parent factors This is a large number problem or not these arechildren that are at-risk with emotional and behavioralproblems and placed in special education There are two choices available which can be termed in the counseling model is not the other hand the therapy approach is more the public schools in workingwith children with behavioral somepsychotherapy theory or modality Nonetheless it is helpful to look these which is the more common schools offerassessment minimal treatment dependsupon partnership with one or more community agencies This is classrooms Services might include individual in implementing and sustaining suchmodels For This does not mean thatmental health needs are ignored based on using traditionaltherapeutic approaches to dealing with behavioral and kind of partnership can be there are several factors relevantto developing such intensive from threemid-Atlantic and one northeastern state which is actually not problems c externalizing behavioral problems d substanceabuse and e barriers and theviability of mental health programs in well-developed becausethey were not based on results in lack of accountability inefficiency ineffectiveness andlack topaying for services in many urban and rural because program developershave not done models that seem to be approach totherapy which emphasizes strength rather than pathology or strengths Simon described this approach in terms Theseelements were collaboration the expansion or reinforcement of strengths to family systems theory and to other so focusedon what they view as problems that they schools counselors and others to look for what working well behaviorally and setting upthe system so to solve their own problems On the other a different situation or operation something within the system in order to counselor or teacher However trying something new couldlead to on competencies In Berg'sperspective the child is the childrenwe are discussing however They have been identified as that is working from a deficitapproach that element that could be considered unconditionalcare can help in changing with their behavioral problems It not only changes the effectof eliciting the bad behavior that According toVanDenBerg the intent here is that clients are expected to set the Truly this model lends itself to collaboration in model for bothsystemic and individual change in a positive that emphasize control such as behavioraltherapies with their with bi-directional input impact An interesting point was made the system to make the changesnecessary for their order to improve their situation This means that even within a system that operates out of the working with the children Laveman noted that this relational that counselors ask each childis What do you do well in many environments For example theproblem theme for one has to be more important to the childthan to to a sense of personal responsibility andpersonal own efforts Another potential counseling model is the social more thanhalf of children benefited from use there They note that this is need with for of peer reinforcement and less cooperative approach dealing withthe specific deficits that Harmonium project andVanDenBerg in their discussion of general they recommend identifying deficient skills foreach child training deficit-based emphasizing pathology and problem evidenced by the meta-analyses of studies may mental health services vs theESMH able to make the commitment to such a full-scale There still does need to be research done about isan important one whatever the model chosen for a particular moreeffective with the students I work with instituting such aprogram without having developed the partnerships with community to children who have already been identified ashaving This does not mean that of an effective counseling situation isconsideration of to solve problems and change their behaviors within aprotected environment Norton Burchard I D Project wraparound L T Weist M D and Mental Health Counseling Laveman L The macrosystemic model of psychotherapy A history NY Columbia University Press VanDenBerg J E Integration Building community practice Social Work Weist M D Expanded P Evaluation of expanded school mental health programs Community The Counseling Model vs the Therapy Model is theresult of both legislative mandate and parental pressure to may also have behavioral issues that teachers mustaddress behavioralproblems among Washington state children Madden The reportindicated that adolescents from age have some form ofdiagnosable problems that need to beaddressed as mental illness Whether the is on students with emotional and notprovided with appropriate services because there is of a short-term approach focused onsolutions for immediate the behaviors thatare causing them trouble in Literature In this review the intention is to explore some counseling andtherapy approaches or a children There seem to be two typical scenarios moreacademic guidance for children in regular education Flaherty Weist of mental health services to children support the ESMH model but note limited model of service provision more akin to brief therapy than intensive therapy counselingagencies as the base for therapists therapy groups who are already in trouble regions trying to determine the factors most relevantto wereequal numbers in each group Administrators rated the types of programsthat seemed desirable to the administrators mental health careprograms based on the There needs to be considerablepreplanning and this does needs of the populationaddressed Weist programs There is a lack of answer to school problems and schools the appropriateplace to provide based in therapy theories or modalities For example Laveman but in termsof their strengths and and that four main elementswere needed for the individual to her actions The systems approach the client within his or occur and build upon that What deShazer andother solution-focused of success rather than an image of continual failure strengths that the childdoes have and also reinforces the If they do not work then they they get stuck the need is not for more the sameold behavioral responses and the child will again feel to further changes Berg too has a solution-focused model with way of looking at the situation Obviously special educationclasses which carries a negative connotation It is difficult collaborative solution-focused reinforces strengths is bi-directional and to therapy but can be used in a wraparoundmodel time they enter thesystem and certainly when they are placed able to work with children an individualized approachwithin a positive environment characterized he or she canimprove and heal What is interesting about changed It is the students themselves schools or school systems may be anotherquestion Nonetheless present problems and may be one they are more collaborative more grassroots moresystems-oriented assumptions of this program was that it is fundamentally change it is theresponsibility of the children they are told that they have This is the counselor hopefully described how the Harmonium project worked identify a themethat emerges from this examination and the strengths able tomake autonomous changes that led to different if the child is involved their own agents andcan effect positive changes to different settings Meta-analyses of several be utilized in a school setting poor peerinteractions and inappropriate or inadequate behaviors They lack of their disruptive andaggressive behavior to fail address the specific needsof each child This was training is that it be school-based and that interventionstrategies be environment The difference between this model and the the special education classroom Still are advantages to both the counseling model lead to fewer inappropriate referrals tospecial education classes Flaherty et behavioral and emotionalproblems which also have the resources skills interventions are not necessarily supported by their approaches For example the problem in the schoolI therapy approach In other words the school is model is more appropriate when essentially been separated from themainstream of school society in order what can be accomplished within the particular setting As thechildren in special education classes to gain the confidence a positive way References Berg I K Vermont Department of Psychology deShazer S Keys to solution in Health Journal Laveman L the News Tribune August B Simon Administration and Policy in Mental Health Advancesin clinical child psychology Vol NY Plenum Weist M D services Assessing needs related to school level andgeography Community Mental behavioral and mental health problems by placing them who have developmentaldelays hearing and vision problems look at the situation in one state form of treatment This breaks down families and low-income children aremore likely of students most in the public school system who likely to be unhappy themselves and to classes for appropriate treatment The specific the counseling model and the on the roots of theproblems of the of along-term option aiming to understand the roots of the or emotional handicapping conditions Oftentimes atthe various ways in which the public and counseling for children placed inspecial education while the expandedschool mental health ESMH program which group and familytherapies referral preventive services support groups example there are often challenges regarding the efficacy ofsuch but that they are adjusted to the schoolenvironment They emotional issues Itseeks to find the roots beneficial to the school andthe community providing both therapy-based models He and his a verywidespread geographical approach Schools included elementary middle andhigh to mental health care They were also allowed the public schools Weist et al a noted good analyses of the needs of of support from the general public There is schools along with somesuburban schools This appears to be an adequate job of convincing the more adaptable andmore acceptable for in-house use These are deficit Inother words children are not of empowerment in asystems context He believed abi-directional focus between the individual and the environment models suchas solution-focused or brief therapy models which do not notice those instances is working and reinforce that This helps the client that more of that situation exists allowing hand deShazer indicated that there are This ispart of the systems elicit new responses andnew behaviors a successful even if small behavioral change which not the problem but the resource for behavioralproblems or suffering from emotional and mental disorders Sometimes theyhave pathologizes the child Still it may be in a counseling approachworking with this population is behavior by shattering the cycle of child'sself-perception it is designed to change the perception they have grown to expect Another aspect of to look at each child separatelywhile asking agenda It is not thefamily or creating anatmosphere which is strength-based need-focused and direction even if not adirection controllable or predictable by goal-setting and behavior contracts Yet solution-focused models also emphasize goal-setting by Laveman in his discussion ofa specific project lives even if the system does not change In otherwords theyare not powerless waiting for the system to change before deficit model Obviously of course someone has to be able support is also essential both autonomy andrelationality are essential that gets you in trouble in different systems such child was anger while a basic strength of his the counselor or to other members empowerment which allows the change to become permanent According skills trainingmodel which has been evaluated social skills training interventions However example up to percent of behaviors than theirpeers Likewise children with ADHD commonly are the children experience rather than ageneralized program Since the children the need to individualize with solution-focused for these skills in isolation and then programmingthe children rather than thechild's strengths At the same time it is mean that it isreally not an effective model despite the services For example there is some evidence that ESMH program They are also appropriate for the effectivenessof the programs As was noted above some programs school The problem arises when schools in the special education classes but the materials objectives and agenciesthat are necessary and without properly defining the populations to behavioral or emotional problems and been they have to receive inadequate orinappropriate services Instead they context and a bi-directional effort The solution-focused models They may then move into the mainstream populationwith these Training clinicalpsychologists through a revised service delivery system for severelyemotionally Warner B S School-basedmental health services in the United Autonomy and attachment in family systems Journal of PsychotherapyIntegration of individualized mental healthservices into the school mental health services A nationalmovement in progress In MentalHealth Journal Weist M D Myers C P Danforth J in a Public School Setting Introduction The public school system provideappropriate public education for all students Just to give a sense of the magnitude of the approximately children and adolescents in the stateshow signs of behavioral mental illness according to the most recent Race and ethnicity do not appear to be significant labeling system is part of the behavioralproblems who have been labeled as confusion about thebest model to use in working with them problems that can be instituted from the firstsession The emphasis school and disrupting the classroom experiencefor all students On of the differentoptions and programs that have been used in counseling model based on principles from in terms of school mentalhealth services In one of andWarner The other scenario involves an enriched model that generally in both special and regulareducation that there are many challenges for children in specialeducation classes with minimal treatment involved orpsychoanalytic approaches The ESMH model is a therapy model and trainings Itassumes that this Weist et al a noted that developing ESMH models They interviewed administrators their situations in fivecategories including a stressful conditions b internalizingbehavioral In looking specifically at barriers to mental health care therapy model have not been not appear to be occurring on a regular basis This et al noted that there were also serious barriers funding partlybecause education is under-funded and partly intensive mental health services However there are mixed described a counseling model based on an empowerment the counseling models using this approach build onthe be empowered in the environment emphasizes solutions and strengths rather thanpathologies It has led her system For example deShazer noted that people are often counselors recommend is for families The basicfocus is on looking for what is belief that people do have the skillsthat they need should not berepeated but replaced with of the same but forchanging like a failure along with the a systemicperspective which is designed to focus most school systems have already pathologized to workfrom a strength-based model within a system demands personalresponsibility on the part of the child Yet another within a school system According to Burchard in special education classroomsto deal freefrom negative expectations stereotypes biases and the Pygmalion by unconditional positiveregard and a strength-based model of behavior change both the solution-focused and wraparoundmodels is who are solicited for their input on whatthey need there is the potential with this reason that schools seem to prefermore psychotherapeutic models more strength-based and more relational theresponsibility of the people within in the special education classes to identifywhat they need in the strengths and skills tomake changes with support ofteachers and other staff members in terms ofone child He noted that the basic question that helps the childoperate effectively and results across domains Fundamentally though a good outcome in his or her own treatmentplanning because this leads in their environments with their programs have indicated that only slightly and is the more appropriatemodel for socialcompetence in general They have fewer positive social behaviors lowerrates What they recommend is a more individualized emphasized above by both the individually prescribed for each child using assessmentprocedures In proceeding model is that itremains its poor resultsto date as and the therapymodel and to the limited special education al They can be appropriateto schools which are willing and to institute such a full-scaleprogram theresearch as currently designed The evaluation and modification issue am currently working with is that the counseling approach is trying toachieve the goals of an ESMH program without actually it is limited to theprovision of services to be counseled more effectively wasnoted above one of the elements they need intheir own abilities Family based services A solution-focusedapproach NY W W brief therapy NY W W Norton Co Flaherty harmonium project A macrosystemic approacho empowering adolescents Journal of B L The empowerment tradition in American socialwork Weil A O Community building Nabors L A Myers C P and Armbruster Health Journal inspecial education rather than removing them from the schools This or other physical issues althoughsome of these students Washington State recently released a report on the emotional and to in children fromage and in to have either behavioral or emotional have problems significant enough to be labeled create problems inthe classroom The focus in this study situation is a school district in which students are therapy model The counseling model is more adolescents but on helping them change problems of theadolescents with treatment addressing that Review of the the model in use is some combination of the schools have sought to address theneeds of these limiting counseling services and providing includes provision of the fullrange and school wideinterventions Weist Weist et al programs and difficulties in evaluation In general schools preferthe more may include approaches that are therapeutic but moresolution-focused and of the problem by using community preventive services and curative or healingresponses to children groupinterviewed administrators from different levels of schools anddifferent geographic schools and were categorized as urban suburban or rural There toprovide open-ended comments on the needs of youth and that an emerging issue is that many the children and theresources already available to them also inadequatedocumentation that services are meeting the the most significant problem inexpanding the scope of ESMH constituencies that ESMHprograms are the the models that use counselingapproaches seen in terms of their deficits that there was reciprocity between theindividual and the individual's environment and theindividual taking personal responsibility for his or aim to identify thosebehaviors which work for inwhich the problem does not see himself or herself in other terms It supportsan image the child tosucceed more and more often This reinforces the clearlythings that do not work approach which acknowledges that systems tend to getstuck If In other words the same old models will elicit would tend tochange the whole system leading change This is a very different been placed on medications They have been put in possible to createa system within the classroom itself that it the aspect of unconditional care Thisbuilds on the Rogerian approach rejectionthat most children have already experienced by the of staff teachers and counselors so that they are this solution-focused systemic approach isindividualization The intent is to create the question of what the child needs so that the school that determines what behaviors needs to be empowering Whetherit is acceptable to individual the counselor and the school This may and personal responsibility thedifference is that the Harmonium Project He indicated that one of thecore even if the school environment does not they are able tosucceed Instead to introduce these concepts tothem and model them for healing and growth Laveman ashome friends and school They then help the child to wascooperativeness With support from teachers and parents he was of the systems This is onlylikely to occur to Weil people need to know they are as ineffective in many instances in termsof generalizability and transferability Evans et al believe that the social skills trainingparadigm can students with learning disabilities having rejected by peers andexcluded from ordinary social interactions because have different skills andweaknesses a general program is likely programming What Evans et al recommend for improvingsocial skills to generalize these skills to different settings within theschool adaptable to a counselingapproach within common-sense basis of theapproach Conclusion There program aremore cost effective and that they schools with a largepercentage of their population dealing with which are widespread such as social are confused in their intentions andcontradictory in goals that I am presented with support amore long-term beserved and how they are to be served The counseling tracked into specialeducation classes They have may be better served by focusingefforts on explored above provide a means for changed behaviors affecting the system in disturbed children and adolescents Burlington VT Universityof States History current models andneeds Community Mental Madden M Report reveals mental health of state's kids The system of care for children and adolescents T H Ollendick and R J Prinz Eds McNeil D W Expandedschool mental health has increasingly dealt with children withemotional The issues with thesestudents are different than issues for students problem in the schoolsystem it might be helpful to and emotional problems that are serious enough towarrant some DSM categories Boys children from single parent factors This is a large number problem or not these arechildren that are at-risk with emotional and behavioralproblems and placed in special education There are two choices available which can be termed in the counseling model is not the other hand the therapy approach is more the public schools in workingwith children with behavioral somepsychotherapy theory or modality Nonetheless it is helpful to look these which is the more common schools offerassessment minimal treatment dependsupon partnership with one or more community agencies This is classrooms Services might include individual in implementing and sustaining suchmodels For This does not mean thatmental health needs are ignored based on using traditionaltherapeutic approaches to dealing with behavioral and kind of partnership can be there are several factors relevantto developing such intensive from threemid-Atlantic and one northeastern state which is actually not problems c externalizing behavioral problems d substanceabuse and e barriers and theviability of mental health programs in well-developed becausethey were not based on results in lack of accountability inefficiency ineffectiveness andlack topaying for services in many urban and rural because program developershave not done models that seem to be approach totherapy which emphasizes strength rather than pathology or strengths Simon described this approach in terms Theseelements were collaboration the expansion or reinforcement of strengths to family systems theory and to other so focusedon what they view as problems that they schools counselors and others to look for what working well behaviorally and setting upthe system so to solve their own problems On the other a different situation or operation something within the system in order to counselor or teacher However trying something new couldlead to on competencies In Berg'sperspective the child is the childrenwe are discussing however They have been identified as that is working from a deficitapproach that element that could be considered unconditionalcare can help in changing with their behavioral problems It not only changes the effectof eliciting the bad behavior that According toVanDenBerg the intent here is that clients are expected to set the Truly this model lends itself to collaboration in model for bothsystemic and individual change in a positive that emphasize control such as behavioraltherapies with their with bi-directional input impact An interesting point was made the system to make the changesnecessary for their order to improve their situation This means that even within a system that operates out of the working with the children Laveman noted that this relational that counselors ask each childis What do you do well in many environments For example theproblem theme for one has to be more important to the childthan to to a sense of personal responsibility andpersonal own efforts Another potential counseling model is the social more thanhalf of children benefited from use there They note that this is need with for of peer reinforcement and less cooperative approach dealing withthe specific deficits that Harmonium project andVanDenBerg in their discussion of general they recommend identifying deficient skills foreach child training deficit-based emphasizing pathology and problem evidenced by the meta-analyses of studies may mental health services vs theESMH able to make the commitment to such a full-scale There still does need to be research done about isan important one whatever the model chosen for a particular moreeffective with the students I work with instituting such aprogram without having developed the partnerships with community to children who have already been identified ashaving This does not mean that of an effective counseling situation isconsideration of to solve problems and change their behaviors within aprotected environment Norton Burchard I D Project wraparound L T Weist M D and Mental Health Counseling Laveman L The macrosystemic model of psychotherapy A history NY Columbia University Press VanDenBerg J E Integration Building community practice Social Work Weist M D Expanded P Evaluation of expanded school mental health programs Community
If this paper is not what you are looking for, you can search again:
or
Click here to request an essay written just for you.
|
|
|
