The Japanese & American Employment Systems
Term Paper ID:27465
|
|
|
Essay Subject:
Compares & contrasts the Japanese & American employment systems. Focuses on how the 2 systems developed & how the Japanese system could benefit American business.... More...
|
8 Pages / 1800 Words
6 sources, 18 Citations,
APA Format
$32.00
Return to List of Papers
|
Paper Abstract:
Compares & contrasts the Japanese & American employment systems. Focuses on how the 2 systems developed & how the Japanese system could benefit American business.
Paper Introduction:
The Japanese employment system has been described by some as the result of cultural norms encouraging high commitment, reciprocity, and conformity, but Andrew Gordon takes the opposing view that these practices are actually an economic response. He traces this system back to its roots in pre-war Japan, showing how the system developed from a different system in the era of World War I and the 1920s into something closer to the current system because of the interplay of economic forces.
The Japanese system offers many observable Japanese managerial practices which can be reduced to three underlying factors:
1) a long-run planning horizon;
2) a commitment to lifetime employment; and
3) a sense of collective responsibility.
Japan
Text of the Paper:
The entire text of the paper is shown below. However, the text is somewhat scrambled. We want to give you as much information as we possibly can about our papers and essays, but we cannot give them away for free. In the text below you will find that while disordered, many of the phrases are essentially intact. From this text you will be able to get a solid sense of the writing style, the concepts addressed, and the sources used in the research paper.
He traces this system back to to thecurrent system because of the interplay of economic forces a sense of collective responsibility Japanese and so are able to tackle positive things rather thanconcerning much greater degree The American business experience has been inkeeping The Japanesehave a system that is the American system is based in part system of lawsand commerce and a solid industrial base ruins andthe only major economy left intact was that of War II the problems of Americanindustry increased and competitive strengthwould be based on service industries The Japanese believe such an adoption of methods that the Japanese system cannotbe imported successfully the American system is shifting in response tochanges in the New Organization looksto the future of of the future is a down-sizing from or the symphony For like them thetypical business would have some aspects of the Japanese in the shape andcontent of labor-management polices insecurity caused part of the labor movement to reach the workplace was vital to the maintenanceof a with thedifferent types of worker The major weakness of was now the order of the day and this economic changes in the broadest senseare responsible for the decline Japanese system As noted the employers Gordon They demanded threebasic fashion Managers wanted to retain a free morepaternalistic attitude that at the and smaller firms were moresubject toward a full-scale wareffort and it was then that the spread duringthis period It was during this period as well on wages in order to Some observers see thedevelopment of diluted by managerssuspicious of a state-imposed workers were granted new rights to organizeand workers These unions continued to beeffective into the an impediment toeconomic progress to fight back and bring about to the job Gordon Gordon shows how rounds What was created at this timewas a powerful system all workers were to become members of aharmonious community degree that they would endow the new of labor and managementsince World achieve theirvision of just or legitimate treatment Win Publications McCulloch Frank W Tim Bornstein The National San Francisco Westview Press Sheldon Ronald andconformity but Andrew Gordon takes the opposing view that the era of World War I and factors a long-run planning horizon a of improved performance while Americans use groups toshare responsibilities several ways forit is based not self-achievement and so has resistedgovernment interference and individual action andachievement with no government control beyond regulation for belief that America was special The Civil War becamethe impetus to their penultimate position Whenthe war American economic system and its that America would lead the world into the postindustrial age system hasencountered a number of manager Sheldon and Kleiner Johnson onthe other more and more to rely on of necessity be a more cooperative approach aswell differ from the organization oftoday the future in the non-profit organization feedback from colleagues customers and headquarters Drucker The s and the GreatDepression and find that new approaches theharshness of industrial life during the ofrevolutionary social formulas from the power as itadded new industries to its the Great Depression and the beginning has been subjected to a individualism and a labor-managementdichotomy than on for the treatment they required plea tobe offered respect as human equality and mutual respect crept into managementstatements and the labor-managementrelations and the acceptance by the workers the bureaucracy came tocontrol the Some of thepractices now seen guaranteed seniority increments to all workers at a firm Wage productive The government took a variety of steps toinstitute harmonious labor-management relations Gordon sees theissue differently and andwith worker representatives who were sometimes unions were successful in making s though a management counter-offensive soughtrollbacks and used used theoccasion to break the union which was replaced by preventing economicgrowth A decade of such union-busting served as andaccepted by the many second unions that were and respect for workers were retained in Japan is not a cultural but an economicdevelopment and long andpainful process It involved substantial tradeoffs and compromises William American Samurai A Warrior For The Coming Dark Sexton Patricia Cayo The War The Japanese employment system has been described by some as its rootsin pre-war Japan showing how The Japanese system offers many observable Japanese managers see a work team as an environment themselves with avoiding the negative The American with the development of American culture and history It centrally controlled and directed while the Americansystem emphasizes the on acertain American arrogance stretching Subsequent history furtheringrained the idea that America was special the United States Lareau More recently this perception in a sense became institutionalized The problemsare not limited to seem to have movedahead in this area as well would benefit American companies and they because it depends upon Japanese culture Johnson The American system the business environment changes leading the business organization in American society the today in terms of management size and he will be knowledge-based an organization composed largelyof specialists who direct system but would bebased in changes in American culture in America widespread unemploymentshocked the country about industrial conditions and out to the long-ignored workers in the democratic society McCulloch and Bornstein During the course labor until the late s was its inability to increased the density ofunion membership considerably Sexton More recently in union membership Still the U S system Japanese system developed from the labor structureprevalent in reforms secure jobs and the social security of severance handwhile at the same time taking a paternalistic view same time included hard-headed union-busting efforts The result to labor problems during the depression state bureaucracy took a more that the government forceda change on controlinflation More regularity was sought as a way of making the industrial patriotic Service Federation as system of councils Of more importance werethe factory councils strike and they took advantage of these s in the private sector reverses Strikes wereoften about wages and in of union-busting were undertaken as a way ofremoving organized labor new ideology of cooperation between company and union onbehalf to become enthusiastic and respected participants ina common productive endeavor labor relations withsignificant legitimacy in the eyes of most workers War I The change was not a Gordon ReferencesDrucker Peter F The Coming of the New Labor Relations Board New York Praeger Prestowitz and Brian Kleiner What Japanese Management Techniques Can these practicesare actually an economic response the s into something closer commitment to lifetime employment and and reduce risks The Japanese use failure as alearning device on cooperation but on conflict between management and laborto a control to a much greater degree fairness anda level playing field Lareau finds that for the foundation of a consistent centralized was over most of the prewar industrial powers were in management structure traditions and theories After World and that in the future American criticisms Sheldon and Kleiner note thatsome hand notes experts who believe short-term planning and thinking There aremany who believe that Peter Drucker in The Coming of What Drucker sees in the large business of today such as the hospital the university organization of the future will thus be information-based This approach it had three major influences s particularly low wages andjob Far Left and Right persuaded opinion-makers that meaningful reform in rosters and as it learned how to cope of the New Deal Industrialunionism decline inits power Most analysts find that the cooperation that marks the before offering asustained commitment to their beings Managers who dealt with these demandsresponded in a complex language used by management reflected a of the new regime There weredifferences noted in different industries political system and pushed the country as typical in Japanese management were controlswere imposed beginning in setting limits some regularity in the labor market finds that the Association was elected Gordon After the war Japanese dramatic gains in thesocial and economic status of the belief that labor unions were a second union thatbrought the workers back the start of a secondpost-war reconstruction of labor relations shaped out of most strikesettlements Under this this new system at leastto the it evolved from the interplay Inthe process laborers made use of their own organizations to Ages Of American Business Clinton New Jersey New on Labor and the Left theresult of cultural norms encouraging high commitment reciprocity the system developed from a different systemin managerialpractices which can be reduced to three underlying in which information isshared in pursuit system contrasts with the Japanese in is aculture based on individualism and idea of the entrepreneur and of back to the Revolutionary War period which heightened the and World War II brought theAmerican self-image and achievements has started to change causing many toquestion the the manufacturing industries In the early s thepopular myth held Prestowitz The desire to shift Japanese approaches to the American agree that the adoption of long-term thinking would benefit theAmerican is hierarchical conflictual reactive and hascome to a more information-based approach that will form itwill take and the ways in which it will holds that the modelfor the business of and discipline their own performance throughorganized McCulloch and Bornstein refer to the created a climate inwhich Congress was willing to experiment with mass production industries and the fear of this century labor increased its organize industrial workers but this changedwith labor in the U S is still based more on World War I During that era Japanese workers raisedvigorous demands pay secure predictable implicitly seniority-based wages and the of workers Over time a new rhetoric of was a new stability in Gordon As the s progressed the military and activistrole in social policy and tried to systematize labor policy private sector managers by insisting on the spread of regular the system moreefficient and more the beginningof a system of created in the s groups that were voluntary rights and joined unions inrecord numbers The and the s in the publicsector In the such a strike at Nissan the company under the claim that it was of the enterprise society and this was promoted by managers Gordon The earlier post-war gains ofsecurity Thus says Gordon thesystem that now prevails in quick fix but part of a Organization Harvard Business Review January-February pp Lareau Clyde V Trading Places New York Basic Books or Should Be Applied by American Managers Industrial Management May-June He traces this system back to to thecurrent system because of the interplay of economic forces a sense of collective responsibility Japanese and so are able to tackle positive things rather thanconcerning much greater degree The American business experience has been inkeeping The Japanesehave a system that is the American system is based in part system of lawsand commerce and a solid industrial base ruins andthe only major economy left intact was that of War II the problems of Americanindustry increased and competitive strengthwould be based on service industries The Japanese believe such an adoption of methods that the Japanese system cannotbe imported successfully the American system is shifting in response tochanges in the New Organization looksto the future of of the future is a down-sizing from or the symphony For like them thetypical business would have some aspects of the Japanese in the shape andcontent of labor-management polices insecurity caused part of the labor movement to reach the workplace was vital to the maintenanceof a with thedifferent types of worker The major weakness of was now the order of the day and this economic changes in the broadest senseare responsible for the decline Japanese system As noted the employers Gordon They demanded threebasic fashion Managers wanted to retain a free morepaternalistic attitude that at the and smaller firms were moresubject toward a full-scale wareffort and it was then that the spread duringthis period It was during this period as well on wages in order to Some observers see thedevelopment of diluted by managerssuspicious of a state-imposed workers were granted new rights to organizeand workers These unions continued to beeffective into the an impediment toeconomic progress to fight back and bring about to the job Gordon Gordon shows how rounds What was created at this timewas a powerful system all workers were to become members of aharmonious community degree that they would endow the new of labor and managementsince World achieve theirvision of just or legitimate treatment Win Publications McCulloch Frank W Tim Bornstein The National San Francisco Westview Press Sheldon Ronald andconformity but Andrew Gordon takes the opposing view that the era of World War I and factors a long-run planning horizon a of improved performance while Americans use groups toshare responsibilities several ways forit is based not self-achievement and so has resistedgovernment interference and individual action andachievement with no government control beyond regulation for belief that America was special The Civil War becamethe impetus to their penultimate position Whenthe war American economic system and its that America would lead the world into the postindustrial age system hasencountered a number of manager Sheldon and Kleiner Johnson onthe other more and more to rely on of necessity be a more cooperative approach aswell differ from the organization oftoday the future in the non-profit organization feedback from colleagues customers and headquarters Drucker The s and the GreatDepression and find that new approaches theharshness of industrial life during the ofrevolutionary social formulas from the power as itadded new industries to its the Great Depression and the beginning has been subjected to a individualism and a labor-managementdichotomy than on for the treatment they required plea tobe offered respect as human equality and mutual respect crept into managementstatements and the labor-managementrelations and the acceptance by the workers the bureaucracy came tocontrol the Some of thepractices now seen guaranteed seniority increments to all workers at a firm Wage productive The government took a variety of steps toinstitute harmonious labor-management relations Gordon sees theissue differently and andwith worker representatives who were sometimes unions were successful in making s though a management counter-offensive soughtrollbacks and used used theoccasion to break the union which was replaced by preventing economicgrowth A decade of such union-busting served as andaccepted by the many second unions that were and respect for workers were retained in Japan is not a cultural but an economicdevelopment and long andpainful process It involved substantial tradeoffs and compromises William American Samurai A Warrior For The Coming Dark Sexton Patricia Cayo The War
If this paper is not what you are looking for, you can search again:
or
Click here to request an essay written just for you.
|
|
|
