ART CRITICISM IN EDUCATION.
Term Paper ID:24337
|
|
|
Essay Subject:
Examines definitions, theories, obstacles, techniques, roles of students & teachers, teaching standards, studio instruction, perceptual & conceptual responses.... More...
|
21 Pages / 4725 Words
18 sources, 56 Citations,
MLA Format
$136.00
Return to List of Papers
|
Paper Abstract:
Examines definitions, theories, obstacles, techniques, roles of students & teachers, teaching standards, studio instruction, perceptual & conceptual responses.
Paper Introduction:
Attempts to set and implement national standards for art instruction have met with little success in the United States. The process of developing such standards has, however, produced a number of novel approaches to teaching art. Among the most prominent innovations are the proposed incorporation of the concepts of art criticism, art history, and aesthetics into the arts curriculum. Yet, to take a single example, the idea of introducing art criticism into teaching has met with enormous resistance from entrenched interests, from those who assign a very low value to arts education, and from numerous parties who simply fail to see how such ideas are relevant to the education of children and teenagers. Reactions to the general idea range from outrage over the apparent desire to eliminate studio art classes, to rejection of the idea based on the inadequate arts
Text of the Paper:
The entire text of the paper is shown below. However, the text is somewhat scrambled. We want to give you as much information as we possibly can about our papers and essays, but we cannot give them away for free. In the text below you will find that while disordered, many of the phrases are essentially intact. From this text you will be able to get a solid sense of the writing style, the concepts addressed, and the sources used in the research paper.
produced a number of novelapproaches to teaching art Among the teaching has met with enormousresistance from are relevant to the education of children elementary and secondaryschools Art criticism Some critics of the idea again becoming an educational priority those who favor isequivalent to the skills used in deciphering written and mathematicalsymbols theconcepts can be incorporated into practice and the value of the averageAmerican school in grades ranging of this time and the remainder is allocated among concepts into the teaching process was according to self-report is best described by McSorley formulated interaction McSorley This however is art criticism ineducation as having teachers and students make art critical concepts in education derives froman understanding of art to acquire lenses or structures of discipline experts Greer This view of writinginstruction As Feldman noted it is a fundamental teacher of readingand literature cited in Stinespring and Kennedy conceptsand activities of various interrelated disciplines artistic creation arthistory the justifications subjectmatter and methods as well as construes the world but none necessarily mean that they also acquire ofhistorical context or style in the painter will only be disciplines are of course closely interrelated If Smith'sdefinition of criticism aestheticsif such assessment were understood as an activity that involves a broader sense than this or contemporary critical judgments and aestheticiansare frequently concerned with general questions about the nature meaning and value feature of art criticism Neithercategory is irrelevant to art criticism art criticism are distinct from those of the others They are the methods by which and use of these methods rather than thediscovery of an evaluated in terms ofwhatever ideal the jobof the teacher to set a particular ideal meetthem Wolff and Geahigan This does not mean an ideal standard is noteven a desirable operate from an ideal that they value teachers critical terms that differfrom those to which they give the possible in their own cultural context it that unless artworks are examined for their human meanings rather is inherent in many artworks to avoid face of art works thatdid not fit which were critical of a about this particular use of cross-cultural study and to narrowly orthodox versions of of standards Inpractice most critics employ an open pragmatic critic But everystudent should have the opportunity learn how to enhance self-expression develop the supposed to become experts in criticism A a reasonedassessment of artistic quality a small way capable of these on thelevel of sophistication she of recognizing deciphering and conveying a sense in the attempt to perceive those pointsof view that emphasize cow or the most obvious aspects of the physicalentity style for example Formal qualities such as color shape line this level Leshnoff Then the criticismin which she makes an initial evaluation cautiously and critic consists largely of the personal draw on her knowledge of the personalreaction of the student and the professional critic it critical methods The personal reaction of a capable of performing this descriptive procedureis then able in which she thinks about art isimproved comments art reviews art historians' assessments andprofessional criticism parts that are the basis anysignificant scale The National Art Education Association form aparallel position to DBAE Greer Yet the emphasis is of the standards has been verylimited and demand fill the art education leadership vacuum is not aggressive in setting forward association positions on example that it has often large number ofAmerican art educators might alleviate in coming thefailure of art educators and the Narrowviews of the function of art arts such as music with itsorchestras and bands if arts instruction is limited toperformance and creation the occasional to focus on what students canlearn beyond the skills needed arts will beviewed as legitimate subjects for some ways of course this is true But theverbal and analytical aspects of art by thefailure of understanding inherent in this argument is that oddly of reading listening writing and talking about and them inother subject areas Yet when they list the learning by looking But the DBAE position is students do not actually learn making art that enables children to learn about art work can develop critical thinking as value the personaldevelopment aspect of studio creativity above other possible benefiting fromthis extended input studio production would become that theysupposed accompanied the older now outmoded content and cultural contexts were taken into account the primary value of art education lay in itsability the firstplace This group also assumed that the addition of critics holddefinite views on the specific function of art ameans of providing students with agroup constitute a powerful lobby in favor of survive as an appealing alternative And othersbelieve educationderives from the failure to see how teachers can use use of the terms criticism set ofspeech acts including the critical statements to perform exploratory inquiring critical activities or skill this important distinction those who created classroom models include critical inquiryin the process would progress in order to describe andanalyze classrooms Art criticism was rendered culturalembeddedness of art works rendered formalism less appealing In addition hoped to apprehend contemporary worksthat stretch traditional interpretive boundaries Walker distinctive tasks that preceded critical speech acts address students' acquisition of these skills in terms of teachingmethods but rather countenances critical skills are developed But and Geahigan Students can be encouraged to talkabout whole units ofinstruction geared to basic critical tasks such engaging in allphases of critical inquiry reaction description analysis personal reaction the initial global intuitive goal is to havestudents engage in goes as far as identification andthen it stops As Wolff they confront a problematic situation Wolff and art to challengestudents prevailing assumption that what they see what they saw in front of them art Wolff and Geahigan But when and howthat knowledge should time of their exposure to the works of artthat are also exposed to the criticalevaluations of those who information relevant onlyduring the later stages proponents recognize however that it is only the synthesis relevantinformation which depends on students' levels of sophistication isavailable during the studentsderive from the work Students who these questions are best answered bystudents themselves for information they are engaged in tryingto satisfy vis the evaluation ofartists success integrating it intothe critical process exemplifies of amethodologically consistent professional model of applicable to art to literature or to history of these higher order skills tends to be of any type of critical thinking the study of art are therefore noless valuable than to consider discipline-based approaches toart instruction Rather than for Education Studies in Art Education Toward a Cross-Cultural Approach through Art History in High School National Art Education Association National Ralph A Smith Art Education A Critical Necessity Urbana U New Art Education A Nationwide Investigation Education Policy Review Smith Ralph A Preface Art Criticism and in Education Stout Candace Jesse Critical Walker Sydney R Thinking Strategies for Interpreting Artworks Studies in in the United States The process the arts curriculum Yet to from numerous parties who simply rejection of the idea based on theinadequate arts student art work or taken to refer to themere history and aesthetics But at a time when the acquisition ofthese skills while artcritical concepts is followed by a discussion the fostering of art critical learning as found that teachers dedicate an average of only hoursper year Mims' and Lankford'scategories were very more than encouraging students to view their own and others' role in the learning process in education Other teachers confusing twomeanings therefore a need toclarify the concept and convey a educationalprocess many scholars now claim that as with Ideally students acquire a moresophisticated ability to understand art time or more art historyand criticism must assume a role vis visman-made imagery that Center for Art Education in California The DBAEapproach mean that the four disciplines are to be taughtindependently ix The tools ofthese disciplines world is accomplished by the means that aremade available experience views works from another methods of painting orsculpture In of art criticism's methods andactivities enables the reasoned criticism Yet the assessment ofmerit could only be irrelevant to questions about thereasons why a work is made or how apparatus to make judgments about herown work art historians often in some sense Art criticism on historian's systematic analysis of the relationshipbetween aesthetics and art history rather than performing the functions themselves Wolff and Geahigan It is thesepractical aspects of critical valuation of its merits guidance in developing an understanding ofhow works of art a vision an ideal ofhow things professional authoritysetting up impossible standards and then their students' attainment of a given ideal or end-goal formalist criticism would have to emerge as an on the individual's critical processes It is often difficult functions of artcriticism in cross-cultural contexts the cultures' formal criteria it is this human context that whetherthey possess artistic merit Anderson student reactions to DuaneHanson's life-like sculptures of lower middle-class Americans responses that modulated from initial disgust andamusement methods to the works thereby dealing with preexistingstandards no one standard issufficient teachers have a number of options a veryfew adhere to a single and Geahigan Of course not every student will become an artist But studentswho Kennedy In acquiring facility in the methods into the classroom setting The functions ofart criticism are to Levi and Smith Yet the student who acquires some the study of art she will applicable to the classroom use of art criticalmethods process of description one views the structural the most substantive andsubtle The description of the Anderson Defining On the simplest level the description addresses the formal relationships within focal point contrast unity and variety are the most of these methods ofdescribing an art the initial judgment Anderson Defining The initial forthe process of understanding the work In any critical approach they may be Thus merely by considering thedifference of knowledge andunderstanding at the same a student who has not received such descriptivemethodology and she is able to conduct will also possess higher expectations with regard toother descriptions of will be enhanced by her ability to like a reasonable standard for artinstruction Yet these ideas have in arteducation are based on the use example is a rapidincrease in teacher preparation on content been low Hatfield Overall resistance to DBAE ideas it must continue to keep itsavenues of dissemination and exposure authoritative voice might help reduce the confusion supported that engendered resistance National ratherthan on politics In addition though political and budgetary any easier Reactions to the DBAE initiative exemplify theresistance to acceptance The strongest opposition to DBAE concepts comes from advocates feel that their efforts should be analogs of end of suchinstruction Instead of attempting to adhere to the understanding andappreciation rather than as a inception Yet studio teacherstend to view it as a other disciplines Stinespring andKennedy argue for example they add a properly equipped studio and reflection They actually advocate art coursesthat are presented as these authors art classes are atime when students the list for an academic discipline-based art course There sacrifices valuable learning by doing them to do It is treat the DBAE claim that much cognitive activity usingall four disciplines in a complementary other art disciplines would put them Another group of critics assumed that of some critics with the process ofcritical views such rigidity was not an intrinsic part of value-free arena of creative expression and this unfolding of students' psyches Anderson Attaining In means of achieving psychological growth None of theseparadigms of they limitthe potential of art Many teachers are anxious to preserve their hard-won territory these are primary sources of opposition to DBAE it mayalso part of the problem stems a set of activities performed by critics set of instructional activities are students need to acquire Unaware that explicitly in terms of the teacherstended to present art criticism as pre-set series lends itself to such step-by-step procedures became the basic knowledge of the formal elements ofart To some open to re-interpretation meant that command of the inall aspects of education that view the acquisition critical inquiry skills as organizedfor the classroom Answers to this question vary according to Wolff and Geahigan For younger children classdiscussion is parts of acomplex whole critical discussion is best in other works of art As childrenreach grades to be compared during class discussion a demonstration of howart criticism is described in technical subject-matter and formal terms they may begin discussion without much prompting But most perceive and object quickly but will only by controversialworks and comparing works of art When the last understood Wolff andGeahigan Their assumption is at this point that background knowledge is an aid Some scholars hold that contextual and simply overwhelm them At the same time that with oradd to the lucidly stated judgments of art not be able to affect themeanings that students have discerned integrated thinking which produces a synthesis of historical information properly belong to the contexts in which works of art were created knowledge needed to enhance their ability to find meanings in finding the answers students will thenfind themselves into the evaluativephase of critical human creative efforts Second it does so by Defining The term critical thinking refers of course to abasic informational level to higher level skills such critical inquiry to artinstruction tends for critical thinking is transferable across contexts Thecritical the ability to think critically to every student Works CitedAnderson Tom Attaining Critical Appreciation Through Conception of Images The Arts Human Development and Education Ed DBAE From Art Education Toward Arts Education Studies in Leshnoff Susan Art Ambiguity and Critical Thinking in Art Education Mims Sandra and Education Association Meeting the Challenges and Linda C Kennedy Discipline-Based Art Education Neglects Learning Education Sullivan Graeme Art-Based Art Education Learning That Is Meaningful and Education Urbana U of Illinois P Attempts to set and implement national standards most prominent innovations are theproposed incorporation of the concepts entrenched interests from those who and teenagers Reactions to the general idea range from outrage is often confused with art history have alsoassumed that criticism is the addition of critical concepts A brief survey of responses doing so Though Wolff and Geahigan claim that art from kindergarten through high school K very little time is art history artcriticism and aesthetics Mims and Lankford This comes attempted by a number of respondents in her study of primary schoolgeneralists' conceptions of only the view of teachers negative remarks aboutworks of art education as a complex and vital process Ratherthan relegating art that weuse to construe the world Greer arteducation implies that the subject's role in the precept of this expandedversion of art The leading versionof this approach is Discipline-Based Art Education art criticism and aesthetics are incorporated exemplify attitudes that are relevant to thecultivation of percipience of them operates entirely on the means peculiar to otherdisciplines When a work is dependent on a knowledge of able toevaluate the potential merit of her work when she seems narrow this is merely because only otherpeople's work which is subjected to strictly it becomes apparent that artcritical thinking is an important component how an art work can have ofartistic expression which is the realm But art critics tend to draw onthe Criticism's methods are the description analysis and evaluation of a critic reasons about the merits of absolute set of critical standards that critical viewer holds In the critical process theindividual as an immutable standard Thelast thing young people need of course thatteachers should not or will situation in the classroom Such a profoundlydisinterested approach canalso foster an openness toward art that admits that there greatest weight But for example Anderson suggests that this becomes clearthat whatever the similarities and differences than just for theirsurface or design qualities the constraints that might be imposed by rigid their preconceived notions of art But lifestyle but still compassionate Leshnoff The gradual change from the Leshnoff's use of artistic ambiguity are important an artideal is itself an ideal for approach toward thediverse and often complex to acquire the tools that make criticalappreciation of vocabulary' of symbolization and become professionalart critic performs a variety of functions to improve the intellectual environment inwhich we think activities A single aspect of critical method will serve develops There are several kinds ofdescription in art criticism Some of the literal illusional andexpressive itsconceptual unity The description approaches the work at a whatever it is that the critic holds to beimportant in itself e g this is oil paint applied light value texture and space and designprinciples critic attempts to relatethe art work to the larger world tentatively andthen uses descriptive methods as the means of reaction to the work of art But art history her experience increating art and her understanding of becomes clear thatstudents are in the student who is educatedin the art to perform the various critical functions Her for herself and for those Finally her ability to appreciate of such values Acquiring familiarity with the NAEA hascalled for improvements and standardization in art education Theassociation's less on rapidimplementation of standards than on eventual re-education of for the NAEA's support materials to assist fullysupportive of the vastly expanded conception of art instruction espoused important issues This is the type of leadership been the power and influence of the Getty some of this misdirected concern thereby allowing education establishment in general toagree on the necessity instruction and a desire to protect alreadyclaimed turf or drama with its staged performances have madeperformance holiday decorations songs forthe season and a holiday pageant can to produce occasional ephemeralentertainments It should be clear that when instruction Greer The DBAE approach has insisted upon the what is replaced is studio instruction having them see how other artistshave dealt with for artteachers Stinespring and Kennedy fail to give much can therefore attractstudents seeking more than just another academic' elements of academic studythat students are trying to that the two types oflearning complement what ispresented to them in a book or lecture Yetthey also claim that the student may simultaneously a DBAE concession to theirpoint of view functions ofart instruction The notions of excellence that would they as rigid and devotedto orthodox methods towhich criticism must be committed Anderson Attaining This No matter how many times thecategories of to enhance human development Psychological growth was content and methodsfrom other disciplines along with the education It is either ameans of developing the tools they need in order maintaining the status quoof studio instruction as the predominant that art instruction properly serves the methods of thevarious disciplines in the classroom In describe analyze and others The confusion results from a common that are the result ofthese in elucidating the verification andjustification of criticism often viewed the disciplineprimarily in terms of the was constrained within the prevailing narrow focus a work of art Wolff and Geahigan Thus into a form of discourse that could be the poststructuralists' insistence that meaning But itwas largely because of the and neednot even produce such acts Once art criticism they must proceed to an analysis of the legitimacy of many kinds ofinstructional activities since the students' stage of cognitive and perceptual their work or teachers might have children as comparison Wolff andGeahigan suggest for example a unit andevaluation For older students the problem of evaluative response and proceed to the process reflection about the work of art But this does and Geahigan put it the difficulty is surmountedwhen the Geahigan Three methods of creating and understand in awork of art is the will be challengedby comparisons of works that take different be acquired and assimilated into the will be subjected to critical inquiry But wrote their textbooks As Anderson notes it of evaluation tend to leave of the various critical tasks thatcan produce the final the process of searching for meanings Stout Critical Therefore are confronted by a variety of worksthat challenge their preconceptions as they engage in library research aimed questions that the critical process raised during theirreflection in meeting goals that they set for themselves Thus the twofold value of teaching studentsabout art First art education art criticism intoteaching is one of the primary In general terms critical thinking consists domain-specific Ittakes place in particular social personal or discipline contexts in general and therefore directly involves engendering those metacognitivecapacities those acquired in other disciplines But when oneconsiders that retreating into the status quo art to Art Criticism Studies in Art Design for Arts in Education Greer W Dwaine Standards A View from the Arts Education of Illinois P McSorley Julie Primary School Teachers' Conceptions Studies in Art Education Qualley Education Theodore F Wolff and George Geahigan Urbana U Conversations About Art A Description of Higher-Order Thinking Art Education Wolff Theodore F ofdeveloping such standards has however take a single example theidea of introducing art criticism into fail to seehow such ideas backgrounds of most teachers in expression of likes and dislikes the development ofcritical thinking skills is once providing students with visual literacy that of the means by which a majorresponsibility the change is slow in coming In exclusively to art instruction Studio production accounts for broad In their study the incorporation of artcritical work in terms of the level of technical accomplishment Thisapproach of students as oneof advocacy rather than as a of the word criticism have even interpreted sense of its value The idea of employing other subjects the purposeof the study of art is ultimately works and will learn to inquirein the manner integrated into other subjects e g history or is analogous to the role of the proposes that art education will be more effective if the Instead they are to supply are the structures with which one to students of the methods of artistic creation this doesnot period her ability to understand the role the case of art criticism judgment of artistic merit Smith ix The art practice art history and it can mean As soon as criticism isconsidered in select works for consideration on the basisof either historical the other hand is seldomconcerned with art of the past and present a Despite the inherent overlap of the disciplines therefore themethods of art criticism that are relevant to the classroom It is however instruction in the development operate and how they can be could be Wolff and Geahigan It is not however the condemning all who fail to Anderson Attaining The complete lack of end initself Even though they for teachers to work in When art works are examined to thegreatest extent givesworks meaning and value Thus the student understands Toward Teachers can also draw on the ambiguity that Thestudents' initial reactions were uncertainty in the with Hanson's people to growing comprehension of his intentions they were not even aware they possessed Anderson's notions for conveying this idea tostudents This refusal to cling vision based on a constraining set every student will become an art learn the methods of making art also of art criticism therefore students are not cultivate artistic perception to make facility withcritical methods is at least in beable to perform critical functions in a limited fashion depending In schools critical description consists relationships of thework of art formally and thematically work also takes into account critic describes the obvious subjectmatter e g this is a the work interms of composition and common guides in the formal analysis ofart works at work allows the student to perform exploratory evaluation of the student or to art the viewer must in the level of sophistication that affects times that they are acquiring skill in deployingart training The student who is a reasoned assessment of the work'squalities The intellectual environment art works that she encounters in conversations instructors' see the relationshipamong the work's not been readily adopted on of the four disciplines and they such as aesthetics andcriticism Qualley Implementation has been strong and the NAEA inthe attempt to open to all points of view alsoneeds to become more and conflictsthat have greeted DBAE-style proposals Greer has noted for leadership from a group that represents a constraints are theprincipal reasons that national standards have been slow change that inhibits consensus on these questions ofstudio instruction Since the other these subjects'approaches Yet as Greer points out performanceparadigm instructors in all the arts need break from serious work the replacement for their type of teaching In that studio teachers involve students in hasreference materials that are available to students Essentially an alternative to yet another class are free of the intellectual rigors imposed on is of course a considerable difference between learning by doingand Stinespring and Kennedy argue that physical involvement withthe processes of in art can come through art production and thatstudio manner Other opponents of discipline-based instruction in a creativestraightjacket Anderson Attaining Rather than art criticism was adiscipline permanently imbued with the outmoded values inquiry which was value-neutral in itself so long as differencesin criticism Finally there wereothers who assumed that wasthe reason art instruction was included in school curricula in each of these types of opposition to DBAE its art education encompasses the notion of art education as education so severely all these positions taken as andbelieve that art can only be true that much of the resistance to discipline-based from theambiguity inherent in the searching for meanings with criticism as a often confounded byuncertainty over whether it is the ability they were failing to make performanceof certain kinds of speech acts any attempt to of discrete steps orstages through which students dominant mode of art critical discourse in American extent deconstructionism's emphasis on the inquiryprocess was essential for anyone who the activities of critical inquiry weretreated as aprimary function of art education As teachers decide to the age ofthe students The DBAE approach is not restrictive the primary mode in which viewed as an adjunct to studiopractice Wolff they are capable of comprehending From junior high school on students are capable of operationalized in the classroom Models of criticism foreducation begin with Anderson Defining In the first phases the teachersfind that observation of the works only begin to thinkabout it to conceptualize when of these methods isselected teachers employ carefully selected works of for example that artists simply tried torepresent accurately tocritical reflection as it suggests alternative possibilities forunderstanding works of historical materials must beavailable to students at the theyreceive this background information they historians Defining But those who consider contextual and historical in the works and historicalknowledge has therefore little importance DBAE description interpretation and evaluation works best when all the the analyticstages following the formulation of personal meanings that Wolff and Geahigan suggest that works of art As studentsengage in this type of search in a much improved position vis inquiry This problem of acquiring knowledge about art and developingstudents' critical thinking skills The incorporation much more than the acquisition of the criticalmethods as synthesis andevaluation Garoian Cognitive psychologists have discovered that thedevelopment therefore to facilitate such development Criticalinquiry reflects the stages tools that are acquired in in the art domain it seemsapparent that art educators need Art Studies in Art Education Defining and Structuring Art Criticism Elliot Eisner Berkeley McCutcheon Garoian Charles R Teaching Critical Thinking Art Education Hatfield Thomas A Art Education Sept Levi Albert William and E Louis Lankford Time Money and the of Reform and Change Arts Theory An Affirmation of Studio Art Design for Arts Authentic Critical and Pluralist Studies in Art Education for art instructionhave met with little success of art criticism art history andaesthetics into assign a very lowvalue to arts education and over the apparent desireto eliminate studio art classes to misinterpretedas a reference to critiques of not possible without extensive grounding inpractice and activities to artinstruction believe that the discipline can advance to the notion of teaching educators have increasinglycome to view devoted exclusively to the study of art Researchers have to hours per year devoted to art criticism and But in general this appears tohave amounted to little teaching art criticism Teachers she found tend to view their who are well disposed toward thenotion of art criticism Wolff and Geahigan There is instruction to a minor frill in the In this approach these structuresare peculiar to each discipline curriculum needs to beexpanded either with more art-exclusive class education that the art teacher DBAE developed underthe aegis of the Getty into instruction This does not in matters of art Smith its own Though for example theinterpretation of the visual the same student with plenty of studio arthistory no matter how much she knows about the is able to use artcritical methods of analysis The study he sought tolimit himself to what was unique to contemporary standards andwhich is considered apart from any philosophical of the other disciplines aswell Each painter uses her critical its effect i e bemeritorious of aesthetics Wolff and Geahigan Nor is the art results of these specific functions of specific works or types of art a work and arrives at a is pursued by arteducators The student needs work is examined against the demands of is the heavy hand of not make conscious content choices thatwill foster would reduce art criticism to a mere technicalexercise in which may be variousideals that make different demands is one of the most valuable in their formal qualities and the viewer will be unable to judge adherence totheir own standards Leshnoff describes their uncertaintyengendered a range of initial response came about as studentsapplied art critical because theydemonstrate the fact that on acknowledging that most professional art critics Only thematic formal and technical aspects of art Wolff art possible In a similar fashion studio instructorsacknowledge that not asskilled as possible in nonverbal communication Stinespring and that do not necessarily lendthemselves to incorporation about art and to appreciate art's multifarious values as an example If astudent has acquired descriptive tools from such as deconstructionist deepdescription are not properties of a visual image Anderson Defining Inthe number oflevels from the most superficial and obvious to the context of her own point of view to a wood panel The nextlevel of such as balance repetition rhythm in physical social or psychological terms Anderson Defining Assimilation searching for those qualitiesthat either support or disprove personal reactions vary in quality or more accurately in usefulness the nature of art no matter howlimited or how extensive process of acquiring these types disciplines will be therefore a very different reaction fromthat of ability toperceive art has been heightened by the acquisition of with whom she may share herdescriptions She the variousvalues of art works methods of art criticism or the otherthree art disciplines seems proposed standards and its statement on excellence teachers Among the NAEA's immediate recommendations for states districts and teachers to implement the standards has byFeldman Greer and others Qualley argues that the NAEA while that is needed and an Center rather than the ideas the center teachers and administrators to concentrate on ideas purposes and goals of art instruction have not madethe process join with incomprehension about DBAE ideas to block theirgeneral the mainstay of educational efforts instructors in the visualarts often appear to be the desired justification for artseducation is made in terms of increasing competency integration of studioinstruction into art education from its thatfunctions without adequate reference to problems of subject matter technique expression andformal organization and attention to theimportance of looking subject emphasesadded Stinespring and Kennedy For avoid they conspicuously omit looking anddo not reformulate each other DBAE opponents argue however thatdiscipline-based instruction they only learn what thatexperience then causes learn something aboutart history criticism and aesthetics They Instead as they fail to recognize DBAE favors presume beimposed on students by expression as these critics presumed art criticism and arthistory were grouptended to confuse the statements art criticism were employed to put forward doctrinaire they held facilitated by the values they embodied wouldinevitably impede the natural self-expression a relativist value-neutral arena forcreativity or a tounderstand evaluate or even to describe art Yet although form of art education in theUnited States only a very limited number ofends Yet though the case of art criticism tendency toconflate critical inquiry which is criticism as acts Wolff and Geahigan Thus educators' attempts toformulate a of critical speech acts that explication of critical statements Then because art criticism was defined on theproduction of critical statements Wolff and Geahigan Thus for example formalist criticism which performedby anyone with an outline and a is never finished but isalways renewed emphasis on critical thinking skills was understood in thisway scholars began to how critical methods are best including class discussion lectures libraryresearch and others developmentprecludes much reflection or making connections among the compare their ownapproaches to subjects with those taken in which different painters'depictions of cities integrating contextual andhistorical materials into critical inquiry provides of description in whichthe object is notoften happen spontaneously If students are interested in a particularwork combined roles of perception and conception are understood Students can such a problematic arethe comparison of alternative responses confrontation only way that it can be seen and approaches to similar subjectmatter It critical processis subject to some debate for high-school students such a procedure may iseasy to imagine students wondering how they can possibly disagree this step until toolate At this point the information will critical evaluation of a work's merits The proponents of the discipline-based approach argue thatcontextual and about the nature of art can raisetheir own questions about at expandingthe amount of biographical and contextual on the works of art In theacquisition of background knowledge moves the students facilitates students' access to theenormous body of means by which students develop these skillsin art courses Anderson of thinking skills that develop from those at Sullivan The addition of the process of associated with higher order thinking Sullivan Thecapacity access to human creative endeavors in the visual artsdepends on educatorsneed to promote standards that truly make art accessible Education Feldman Edmund Burke Art Education and the Developments in Discipline-Based Art Education Associations Arts Education Policy Review of Teaching Art Criticism Studies Charles A The National Arts of Illinois P ix-x Stinespring John A Generated through the Study of Art Criticism Studies in Art and George Geahigan Art Criticism produced a number of novelapproaches to teaching art Among the teaching has met with enormousresistance from are relevant to the education of children elementary and secondaryschools Art criticism Some critics of the idea again becoming an educational priority those who favor isequivalent to the skills used in deciphering written and mathematicalsymbols theconcepts can be incorporated into practice and the value of the averageAmerican school in grades ranging of this time and the remainder is allocated among concepts into the teaching process was according to self-report is best described by McSorley formulated interaction McSorley This however is art criticism ineducation as having teachers and students make art critical concepts in education derives froman understanding of art to acquire lenses or structures of discipline experts Greer This view of writinginstruction As Feldman noted it is a fundamental teacher of readingand literature cited in Stinespring and Kennedy conceptsand activities of various interrelated disciplines artistic creation arthistory the justifications subjectmatter and methods as well as construes the world but none necessarily mean that they also acquire ofhistorical context or style in the painter will only be disciplines are of course closely interrelated If Smith'sdefinition of criticism aestheticsif such assessment were understood as an activity that involves a broader sense than this or contemporary critical judgments and aestheticiansare frequently concerned with general questions about the nature meaning and value feature of art criticism Neithercategory is irrelevant to art criticism art criticism are distinct from those of the others They are the methods by which and use of these methods rather than thediscovery of an evaluated in terms ofwhatever ideal the jobof the teacher to set a particular ideal meetthem Wolff and Geahigan This does not mean an ideal standard is noteven a desirable operate from an ideal that they value teachers critical terms that differfrom those to which they give the possible in their own cultural context it that unless artworks are examined for their human meanings rather is inherent in many artworks to avoid face of art works thatdid not fit which were critical of a about this particular use of cross-cultural study and to narrowly orthodox versions of of standards Inpractice most critics employ an open pragmatic critic But everystudent should have the opportunity learn how to enhance self-expression develop the supposed to become experts in criticism A a reasonedassessment of artistic quality a small way capable of these on thelevel of sophistication she of recognizing deciphering and conveying a sense in the attempt to perceive those pointsof view that emphasize cow or the most obvious aspects of the physicalentity style for example Formal qualities such as color shape line this level Leshnoff Then the criticismin which she makes an initial evaluation cautiously and critic consists largely of the personal draw on her knowledge of the personalreaction of the student and the professional critic it critical methods The personal reaction of a capable of performing this descriptive procedureis then able in which she thinks about art isimproved comments art reviews art historians' assessments andprofessional criticism parts that are the basis anysignificant scale The National Art Education Association form aparallel position to DBAE Greer Yet the emphasis is of the standards has been verylimited and demand fill the art education leadership vacuum is not aggressive in setting forward association positions on example that it has often large number ofAmerican art educators might alleviate in coming thefailure of art educators and the Narrowviews of the function of art arts such as music with itsorchestras and bands if arts instruction is limited toperformance and creation the occasional to focus on what students canlearn beyond the skills needed arts will beviewed as legitimate subjects for some ways of course this is true But theverbal and analytical aspects of art by thefailure of understanding inherent in this argument is that oddly of reading listening writing and talking about and them inother subject areas Yet when they list the learning by looking But the DBAE position is students do not actually learn making art that enables children to learn about art work can develop critical thinking as value the personaldevelopment aspect of studio creativity above other possible benefiting fromthis extended input studio production would become that theysupposed accompanied the older now outmoded content and cultural contexts were taken into account the primary value of art education lay in itsability the firstplace This group also assumed that the addition of critics holddefinite views on the specific function of art ameans of providing students with agroup constitute a powerful lobby in favor of survive as an appealing alternative And othersbelieve educationderives from the failure to see how teachers can use use of the terms criticism set ofspeech acts including the critical statements to perform exploratory inquiring critical activities or skill this important distinction those who created classroom models include critical inquiryin the process would progress in order to describe andanalyze classrooms Art criticism was rendered culturalembeddedness of art works rendered formalism less appealing In addition hoped to apprehend contemporary worksthat stretch traditional interpretive boundaries Walker distinctive tasks that preceded critical speech acts address students' acquisition of these skills in terms of teachingmethods but rather countenances critical skills are developed But and Geahigan Students can be encouraged to talkabout whole units ofinstruction geared to basic critical tasks such engaging in allphases of critical inquiry reaction description analysis personal reaction the initial global intuitive goal is to havestudents engage in goes as far as identification andthen it stops As Wolff they confront a problematic situation Wolff and art to challengestudents prevailing assumption that what they see what they saw in front of them art Wolff and Geahigan But when and howthat knowledge should time of their exposure to the works of artthat are also exposed to the criticalevaluations of those who information relevant onlyduring the later stages proponents recognize however that it is only the synthesis relevantinformation which depends on students' levels of sophistication isavailable during the studentsderive from the work Students who these questions are best answered bystudents themselves for information they are engaged in tryingto satisfy vis the evaluation ofartists success integrating it intothe critical process exemplifies of amethodologically consistent professional model of applicable to art to literature or to history of these higher order skills tends to be of any type of critical thinking the study of art are therefore noless valuable than to consider discipline-based approaches toart instruction Rather than for Education Studies in Art Education Toward a Cross-Cultural Approach through Art History in High School National Art Education Association National Ralph A Smith Art Education A Critical Necessity Urbana U New Art Education A Nationwide Investigation Education Policy Review Smith Ralph A Preface Art Criticism and in Education Stout Candace Jesse Critical Walker Sydney R Thinking Strategies for Interpreting Artworks Studies in in the United States The process the arts curriculum Yet to from numerous parties who simply rejection of the idea based on theinadequate arts student art work or taken to refer to themere history and aesthetics But at a time when the acquisition ofthese skills while artcritical concepts is followed by a discussion the fostering of art critical learning as found that teachers dedicate an average of only hoursper year Mims' and Lankford'scategories were very more than encouraging students to view their own and others' role in the learning process in education Other teachers confusing twomeanings therefore a need toclarify the concept and convey a educationalprocess many scholars now claim that as with Ideally students acquire a moresophisticated ability to understand art time or more art historyand criticism must assume a role vis visman-made imagery that Center for Art Education in California The DBAEapproach mean that the four disciplines are to be taughtindependently ix The tools ofthese disciplines world is accomplished by the means that aremade available experience views works from another methods of painting orsculpture In of art criticism's methods andactivities enables the reasoned criticism Yet the assessment ofmerit could only be irrelevant to questions about thereasons why a work is made or how apparatus to make judgments about herown work art historians often in some sense Art criticism on historian's systematic analysis of the relationshipbetween aesthetics and art history rather than performing the functions themselves Wolff and Geahigan It is thesepractical aspects of critical valuation of its merits guidance in developing an understanding ofhow works of art a vision an ideal ofhow things professional authoritysetting up impossible standards and then their students' attainment of a given ideal or end-goal formalist criticism would have to emerge as an on the individual's critical processes It is often difficult functions of artcriticism in cross-cultural contexts the cultures' formal criteria it is this human context that whetherthey possess artistic merit Anderson student reactions to DuaneHanson's life-like sculptures of lower middle-class Americans responses that modulated from initial disgust andamusement methods to the works thereby dealing with preexistingstandards no one standard issufficient teachers have a number of options a veryfew adhere to a single and Geahigan Of course not every student will become an artist But studentswho Kennedy In acquiring facility in the methods into the classroom setting The functions ofart criticism are to Levi and Smith Yet the student who acquires some the study of art she will applicable to the classroom use of art criticalmethods process of description one views the structural the most substantive andsubtle The description of the Anderson Defining On the simplest level the description addresses the formal relationships within focal point contrast unity and variety are the most of these methods ofdescribing an art the initial judgment Anderson Defining The initial forthe process of understanding the work In any critical approach they may be Thus merely by considering thedifference of knowledge andunderstanding at the same a student who has not received such descriptivemethodology and she is able to conduct will also possess higher expectations with regard toother descriptions of will be enhanced by her ability to like a reasonable standard for artinstruction Yet these ideas have in arteducation are based on the use example is a rapidincrease in teacher preparation on content been low Hatfield Overall resistance to DBAE ideas it must continue to keep itsavenues of dissemination and exposure authoritative voice might help reduce the confusion supported that engendered resistance National ratherthan on politics In addition though political and budgetary any easier Reactions to the DBAE initiative exemplify theresistance to acceptance The strongest opposition to DBAE concepts comes from advocates feel that their efforts should be analogs of end of suchinstruction Instead of attempting to adhere to the understanding andappreciation rather than as a inception Yet studio teacherstend to view it as a other disciplines Stinespring andKennedy argue for example they add a properly equipped studio and reflection They actually advocate art coursesthat are presented as these authors art classes are atime when students the list for an academic discipline-based art course There sacrifices valuable learning by doing them to do It is treat the DBAE claim that much cognitive activity usingall four disciplines in a complementary other art disciplines would put them Another group of critics assumed that of some critics with the process ofcritical views such rigidity was not an intrinsic part of value-free arena of creative expression and this unfolding of students' psyches Anderson Attaining In means of achieving psychological growth None of theseparadigms of they limitthe potential of art Many teachers are anxious to preserve their hard-won territory these are primary sources of opposition to DBAE it mayalso part of the problem stems a set of activities performed by critics set of instructional activities are students need to acquire Unaware that explicitly in terms of the teacherstended to present art criticism as pre-set series lends itself to such step-by-step procedures became the basic knowledge of the formal elements ofart To some open to re-interpretation meant that command of the inall aspects of education that view the acquisition critical inquiry skills as organizedfor the classroom Answers to this question vary according to Wolff and Geahigan For younger children classdiscussion is parts of acomplex whole critical discussion is best in other works of art As childrenreach grades to be compared during class discussion a demonstration of howart criticism is described in technical subject-matter and formal terms they may begin discussion without much prompting But most perceive and object quickly but will only by controversialworks and comparing works of art When the last understood Wolff andGeahigan Their assumption is at this point that background knowledge is an aid Some scholars hold that contextual and simply overwhelm them At the same time that with oradd to the lucidly stated judgments of art not be able to affect themeanings that students have discerned integrated thinking which produces a synthesis of historical information properly belong to the contexts in which works of art were created knowledge needed to enhance their ability to find meanings in finding the answers students will thenfind themselves into the evaluativephase of critical human creative efforts Second it does so by Defining The term critical thinking refers of course to abasic informational level to higher level skills such critical inquiry to artinstruction tends for critical thinking is transferable across contexts Thecritical the ability to think critically to every student Works CitedAnderson Tom Attaining Critical Appreciation Through Conception of Images The Arts Human Development and Education Ed DBAE From Art Education Toward Arts Education Studies in Leshnoff Susan Art Ambiguity and Critical Thinking in Art Education Mims Sandra and Education Association Meeting the Challenges and Linda C Kennedy Discipline-Based Art Education Neglects Learning Education Sullivan Graeme Art-Based Art Education Learning That Is Meaningful and Education Urbana U of Illinois P
If this paper is not what you are looking for, you can search again:
or
Click here to request an essay written just for you.
|
|
|
